Spoiled: Organic and Local Is So 2008
"Food is not simple. To make it, you have to balance myriad variables—soil, water, and nutrients, of course, but also various social, political, and economic realities. But because our consumer culture favors fixes that are fast and easy, our approaches toward food advocacy have been built around one or two dimensions of production, such as reducing energy use or eliminating pesticides, while overlooking factors that are harder to define (and ditto to market), such as worker safety.'There's much more worth reading."Consider our love affair with food miles. In theory, locally grown foods have traveled shorter distances and thus represent less fuel use and lower carbon emissions—their resource footprint is smaller. And yet, for all the benefits of a local diet, eating locally doesn't always translate into more sustainability. Because the typical farmers market is supplied by dozens of different farms, each transporting its crops in a separate van or truck, a 20-pound shopping basket of locally grown produce might actually represent a larger carbon footprint than the same volume of produce purchased at a chain retailer, which gets its produce en masse, via large trucks."
"And for all our focus on the cost of moving food, transportation accounts for barely one-tenth of a food product's greenhouse gas emissions. Far more significant is how the food was produced—its so-called resource intensity. Certain foods, like meat and cheese, suck up so many resources regardless of where they're produced (a pound of conventional grain-fed beef requires nearly a gallon of fuel and 5,169 gallons of water) that you can shrink your footprint far more by changing what you eat, rather than where the food came from. According to a 2008 report from Carnegie Mellon University, going meat- and dairyless one day a week is more environmentally beneficial than eating locally every single day."
4 comments:
It's true, it's a dilemma.
My best solution to balance all the issues is buying my produce from a grower's outlet. The food there is what I call "semi-local", meaning, for instance, bananas from California rather than from Central America. Most everything there comes from Oregon growers, most of the rest from a 1-state radius in any direction. There may be a few exceptions, but none that I've seen.
The reality is Oregon doesn't have the same growing season as some other areas, so limiting ourselves to local-only would cause our diets more likely to be deficient during the winter/spring months. Likewise, we can't even grow bananas here in the summer.
Native Alabamian here...I was born and raised in the Huntsville area...
Love your blog.
erin-
I'm still looking for my best solution...
Phil-
thanks for stopping by! I hope to see you again in the deep south blogland. :-)
We have much yet to learn about all of these issues. They are far more complex than it appears on the surface. It will take an active investigation and good deal of skepticism on all sources before we arrive at sustainable solutions. In my view, it is likely we will have to transition to better solutions over time, not jump to an "answer" today that will be "the" answer for all time.
Post a Comment